In theory, England’s recent match against Chile looked like a prime opportunity for some of the fringe players to make a strong case for their inclusion in the starting lineup. But as it turns out, theory and practice often differ, especially in the world of rugby.
Henry Arundell, the man with five tries to his name in that match, and Marcus Smith, who brought a livewire performance to the full-back position, certainly caught the eye. However, whether this will be enough to convince England’s head coach, Steve Borthwick, to reshuffle his starting XV for the more challenging tests ahead is a different story altogether.
Borthwick is a coach with a distinct style, one that relies heavily on risk-averse rugby, a philosophy that leans on percentages and analytics. It’s a gameplan centered around kicking for territory and putting immense pressure on the opposition’s back three. This approach doesn’t leave much room for individual initiative and instinct; instead, it thrives on well-drilled, pre-set patterns.
While Arundell and Smith showcased their attacking prowess, it’s doubtful if their style aligns with Borthwick’s tighter, more prescriptive gameplan. Borthwick seems to value players who fit seamlessly into his system, and these two, for all their talent, might not be the perfect fit.
Arundell displayed not only his running abilities but also his patience and ability to finish off moves. On the other hand, Smith injected speed and intelligence into England’s attack, particularly when launching counterattacks from deep. However, these qualities may not align with what Borthwick values most.
In essence, what Arundell and Smith did was underline their readiness to step up when needed, be it due to injuries or tactical changes. They’ve put their names in the hat, but the starting XV remains a distant prospect for now.
One player who seems destined to stay in the starting lineup is Owen Farrell. Borthwick has showered him with praise, highlighting his influence on the squad and his ability to elevate the team’s standards. Farrell is, in many ways, Borthwick’s on-field lieutenant, a trusted figure who orchestrates the game.
However, here’s where things get interesting. My preference, and perhaps a more dynamic approach, would be to keep George Ford at fly-half, with Manu Tuilagi and Joe Marchant forming the midfield partnership. Tuilagi’s direct, powerful running style and Marchant’s well-rounded skills make for an enticing combination. This balance offers England a multifaceted attack.
In knockout stages, versatility becomes crucial. Relying solely on penalties, drop-goals, and set-piece plays isn’t enough. England needs more dimensions to their game. The running lines and ambition displayed against Chile should become a permanent part of their playbook.
Looking ahead to potential matchups against Australia, Fiji, or even Wales, England’s gameplan should adapt. Against teams without a strong kicking game, having someone like Smith at full-back could provide an extra attacking edge.
In summary, while Arundell and Smith showcased their abilities, Steve Borthwick’s coaching philosophy and the need for a well-structured system may limit their immediate prospects in the starting lineup. It’s a delicate balance between individual brilliance and team cohesion, and the debate over England’s optimal lineup will continue as they progress through the tournament. The extended break before their next match against Samoa gives Borthwick plenty of time to ponder his selections and perhaps consider incorporating some of the flair displayed against Chile into their gameplan.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Rugby Selection Dilemma
Q: Who is Steve Borthwick, and what is his coaching philosophy?
A: Steve Borthwick is the head coach of the England rugby team. His coaching philosophy is centered around risk-averse rugby, which heavily relies on percentages and analytics. It involves strategies such as kicking for territory and putting pressure on the opposition’s back three. Borthwick’s coaching approach prioritizes well-drilled, pre-set patterns over individual initiative and instinct.
Q: How did Henry Arundell and Marcus Smith perform in the recent England vs. Chile match?
A: Henry Arundell had an outstanding performance, scoring five tries and showcasing his running abilities, patience, and finishing skills. Marcus Smith delivered a livewire performance, particularly in counterattacks from the full-back position, adding speed and intelligence to England’s attack.
Q: Will Henry Arundell and Marcus Smith likely be included in the starting XV for England’s tougher tests?
A: The text suggests that it’s unlikely Henry Arundell and Marcus Smith will immediately find a place in the starting XV for England’s tougher matches. Steve Borthwick’s coaching philosophy values players who fit well into his risk-averse, well-structured gameplan, and these two players may not align perfectly with that approach.
Q: Who are the preferred choices for key positions in England’s lineup according to the article?
A: Owen Farrell is mentioned as a trusted figure who is likely to stay in the starting lineup, potentially at inside centre. The author also suggests that George Ford at fly-half, Manu Tuilagi at outside centre, and Joe Marchant as a well-rounded outside centre could form a dynamic midfield partnership.
Q: What is the author’s opinion on England’s playing style in the knockout stages of the tournament?
A: The author argues that England should adapt their playing style in the knockout stages, emphasizing versatility. Relying solely on penalties, drop-goals, and set-piece plays may not be sufficient. The author encourages the incorporation of the running lines and ambition displayed in the match against Chile into England’s gameplan to add more dimensions to their attack.
More about Rugby Selection Dilemma
- Steve Borthwick
- Henry Arundell
- Marcus Smith
- England Rugby
- Rugby World Cup
- George Ford
- Manu Tuilagi
- Joe Marchant
4 comments
England’s gameplan? It’s a debate. Arundell, Smith, they want in. Borthwick’s call, tho. Gotta adapt for the big games.
Farrell, trusted by Borthwick, likely to stay. Ford, Tuilagi, Marchant – good midfield? Maybe. Need more than kicks in knockout stages. Gotta mix it up.
coach borthwick got his own style, no doubt. kickin, territory, and stats, that’s his game. But Arundell n Smith, they shone, tho maybe not Borthwick’s cuppa tea.
Arundell 5 tries, wow! Smith speedy guy. But coach Borthwick, he likes structure. Not sure bout these two fit the bill.